Coney Island Pizza

40 Hamburg Tpke, Riverdale, NJ 07457 Order now
Hero image

Fantastic Pizza


Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Coney Island Pizza Reviews on Grubhub


1 review
It was the first time ordering and im more than happy with the experience.
Thank You sooo much for the great suprise for my boyfriend!!! The pizza was delicious and arrived on time!! And a special Thank You for the extra effort to write on the box what i asked!!! Very satisfied:)))


4 reviews
The brick oven pizza is amazing! Its my new favorite go to place for pizza. The meatball sliders were good but too much bun and not enough meatball. Havent had a bad experience yet!


1 review
Good restaurant! Nice people, great food. Tough to find parking but I don't know the area well so maybe I missed something obvious.


1 review
Love the arrival
Time and food is delicious and to my expectations due to having food allergies.


Top Reviewer
Love this place! Food is always delicious. Order is always correct and delivery is on time.

Reviews from

Coney Island Pizza Reviews on Seamless


4 reviews
Fast delivery, great food

About us

American, Dessert, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches