Coney Island Pizza
HomeMenuReviewsAboutOrder now

Coney Island Pizza Menu

Beverages


Soda

$1.75 +

San Pellegrino

$2.50

Water

$1.75

From the Garden


Mozzarella Caprese Salad

Beefsteak tomatoes, homemade fresh mozzarella, and basil, with balsamic glaze.

$9.00 +

Baby Bella Salad

Baby spinach, baby bella mushrooms, roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes, and blue cheese crumbles with balsamic vinegar.

$8.50 +

Caesar Salad

Hearts of romaine, Pecorino Romano, cherry tomatoes, and pretzel croutons with creamy Caesar dressing.

$7.00 +

House Salad

Romaine lettuce, red onions, roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes, balsamic vinegar and Olive Oil

$6.50 +

Spicy Ramstein Salad

Baby spinach, roasted chickpeas, corn, red peppers, black beans, and goat cheese with homemade Ramstein dressing.

$8.50 +

Arugula Prosciutto Salad

Arugula, prosciutto, shaved Pecorino Romano, and cherry tomatoes with homemade lemon garlic vinaigrette.

$9.00 +

Wedge Salad

Iceberg wedges topped with bacon, blue cheese crumbles, and beefsteak tomatoes finished with blue cheese dressing.

$7.00 +

Antipasto Salad

Crispy romaine, provolone cheese, assorted Italian cured meats and roasted red peppers.

$9.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Crispy romaine hearts, chicken, bruschetta, bacon, blue cheese crumbles, ranch dressing and Buffalo sauce.

$9.00 +

Wood Fired Pizza


Margherita Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, Pecorino Romano, basil, and seasonings.

$11.00 +

White Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, ricotta impastata, fresh garlic, basil, and seasonings.

$12.50 +

3P Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, pistachio pesto, Pecorino Romano, seasonings, fresh garlic, and basil.

$12.50 +

BBQ Chicken Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, wood fried chicken, BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, red onions, and chipotle ranch.

$14.50 +

White Clam Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, fresh shucked clams, fresh garlic, basil, white wine, and seasonings.

$14.50 +

Pizza Verde Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, fresh garlic, arugula, basil, prosciutto, and seasonings.

$14.50 +

Shrimp Scampi Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, fresh garlic, wood fired shrimp, bruschetta, and seasonings.

$14.50 +

Pulled Pork Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, BBQ sauce, pulled pork, yellow onions, cheddar cheese, corn, and chipotle ranch.

$14.50 +

Buffalo Chicken Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, wood fire chicken, Buffalo sauce, bacon, and blue cheese crumbles.

$14.50 +

Popeye Pizza

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, ricotta impastata, fresh garlic, basil, spinach, bruschetta, and seasonings.

$14.50 +

Meatball Impastata Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, ricotta impastata, San Marzano tomato sauce, wood fired meatballs, basil, and seasonings.

$14.50 +

5 Boro Pie

Fresh mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese, Pecorino Romano cheese, pepperoni, and sopresetta.

$14.00

Brooklyn Bridge Pie

Fresh mozzarella, basil, San Marzano tomato sauce with a creamy layer of pecorino Romano on top.

$11.50 +

Chipotle Chicken Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, Pecorino Romano cheese, chicken, spinach, roasted red peppers, and bacon, with a homemade chipotle ranch drizzle.

$14.00 +

Lower Eastside Pie

Fresh mozzarella cheese, pecorino Romano cheese, basil, garlic, spinach tossed in lemon garlic vinaigrette and artichokes.

$14.00

Salad Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, fresh garlic, arugula, roasted peppers, red onions, seasonings, basil, and lemon garlic vinaigrette.

$13.50 +

Southwestern Pie

Fresh mozzarella, cheddar, Pecorino Romano, chicken, roasted jalapenos, corn bean salsa and with a lime cream cilantro sauce.

$14.00 +

Spring Break Pie

Fresh mozzarella, shrimp, garlic, Pecorino Romano and avocado salsa with a sriracha crema sauce.

$14.00 +

Sunset Park Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, Pecorino Romano cheese, mascarpone, chicken, lemon pepper seasoning, banana peppers, and garlic.

$14.00 +

Truffle Shuffle Pie

12" and made to order with Pecorino Romano, sea salt, and black pepper. Fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, fresh garlic, asparagus, sun-dried tomatoes, basil, and seasonings.

$14.50 +

Summer BBQ

Fresh Mozzarella, Wood-Fired Chicken, Monterrey Cheddar, bacon, red onion, bruschetta, BBQ sauce

$14.00 +

Spicy Sausage and a Tomato Pie

San Marzano Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Spicy Sausage, Ricotta Impastata, and Bruschetta

$14.00 +

Mushroom & Arugula Pie

Fresh Mozzarella, Baby Portobello Mushrooms, Garlic, Red Onion, Arugula, Balsamic Truffle Glaze Drizzle

$14.00

Flatbread Sandwiches


Balsamic Chicken Flatbread

Wood fried chicken, spinach, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella, with balsamic glaze.

$9.50

Buffalo Chicken Flatbread

Wood fired chicken, spinach, blue cheese crumbles, and bruschetta, with Buffalo sauce.

$9.50

Caprese Flatbread

Beefsteak tomatoes, homemade fresh mozzarella, and basil, with balsamic glaze.

$9.00

Roasted Vegetable Flatbread

Fresh roasted market vegetables, baby spinach, fresh homemade mozzarella, and bruschetta, with balsamic glaze.

$9.50

Pepperoni Flatbread

Fresh mozzarella, provolone, and pepperoni, with a side of marinara.

$9.00

Prosciutto & Mozzarella Flatbread

Prosciutto, fresh homemade mozzarella, beefsteak tomatoes, and basil, with balsamic glaze.

$9.50

Chipotle Chicken Flatbread

Wood fried chicken, spinach, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and bacon, with homemade chipotle ranch.

$9.50

Garlic Flatbread

Freshly baked flatbread, Pecorino Romano, sea salt, black pepper, and fresh garlic.

$6.00

Garlic Flatbread with Cheese

$6.50

Messy Meatball Parm Flatbread

Homemade wood fired meatballs, fresh mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano with a side of marinara.

$9.00

Chicken Caesar Flatbread

Spinach, pecorino, tomato and Caesar dressing.

$9.00

Loaded Flatbread

Our flatbread loaded with fresh mozzarella, cheddar cheese, bacon, pecorino Romano, scallions and ranch dressing.

$7.00

Wood Fired Specialties


Wood Fired Wings

Choice of style

$11.00

Pulled Pork Sliders

Pulled pork served on slider buns with chipotle ranch and BBQ sauce with a side of pretzel chips.

$8.50

Jalapeno Poppers

Wood fired jalapenos, ricotta impastata, cheddar cheese, bacon, and Pecorino Romano, with a side of chipotle ranch.

$7.50

Clams al Forno

Wood fired little neck clams served in a white wine garlic sauce.

$11.00

Roasted Asparagus

Wood fired asparagus, fresh garlic, Pecorino Romano, and roasted cherry tomatoes.

$8.00

Meatball Sliders

Wood fired meatballs served on slider buns with marinara and Pecorino Romano with a side of pretzel chips.

$8.00

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Our homemade Buffalo chicken dip with a freshly made flatbread to order.

$9.00

Mussels al Forno

P.E.I. mussels served in a spicy red sauce with yellow onions, roasted red peppers, basil and fresh garlic.

$10.00

Wood-Fired Salmon

$16.00

Desserts


Apple Pie

Freshly baked pizza dough with Granny Smith apples, brown sugar, and cinnamon.

$10.00

Green Tea Cannoli

2 large cannoli shells filled with our homemade matcha cannoli cream.

$6.00

Tiramisu

Lady fingers soaked in espresso and Marsala wine, with our homemade tiramisu cream.

$5.50

Banana Nutella

Freshly baked pizza dough with fresh sliced bananas, brown sugar, cinnamon, and warm Nutella drizzle.

$10.00

Banana Foster

Golden pound cake and homemade cannoli cream with caramelized bananas.

$6.00

Peppermint Patty Cannoli

2 large cannoli shells filled with our homemade peppermint patty cannoli cream.

$6.00

Red Velvet Cannoli

2 large cannoli shells filled with our homemade red velvet cannoli cream.

$6.00

Cannoli

Large cannoli shells filled with homemade cannoli cream.

$5.50

Coney Island Pizza

A leading Riverdale restaurant on Grubhub

40 Hamburg Tpke, Riverdale, NJ 07457
(973) 476-9223
© 2025 Grubhub Holdings Inc.Terms of usePrivacy policyCA privacy noticeDo not sell my info